Fail or Win?

My sister, Jessica, is what some girls call a "Belieber." Huge Justin Bieber fan. Her birthday was the 12th and I know she wanted something Justin Bieber-ish. What major fan wouldn't want something that no other Justin Bieber fan had? A one of a kind?
So that's what I did. I made her this following the Funambulist Damsel blog.
My sister liked it and that's all that counts. But my expectations weren't met. Don't you hate when you have a great idea and it doesn't come through? So what do you think? Was this a fail or a win?